International Association for Property and Evidence, Inc.
Evidence Log - 1994 Vol 94, No 1

Disposing of Tapes and Photographs 

Video Tapes, photographs and voice recordings provide a unique disposal problem. They give the viewer/listener a personal, next to "being there" awareness. It is not uncommon to hear of a story about problems with disposal. One agency had cut up photos, then placed them in a large dumpster waiting for the trash pickup. The dumpster was located on City property, kept closed and was surrounded by a chain link fence. The photos had been placed in the dumpster the day pickup was due. Several days later an irate father came in with some cut-up crime scene photos his energetic son had recovered from the dumpster and taped back together. Even though the father admitted his son had been trespassing, the City had to settle a costly legal action for "traumatic stress" the boy suffered as a result of the incident. Complete disposal of video tapes and photographs is essential to preserve the integrity of the agency, while reducing potential liability. 

Options for the disposal of tapes/photographs: 

Shredding - completely destroys the photograph. (Videos/cassettes may be destroyed in much the same manner by cutting the tape into small pieces). Possible problem: Only recommended for a high volume, high grade shredder due to the potential of jamming a low volume unit. 

Incineration: Completely destroys the photographs/tapes; can often be done as part of a narcotics burn (closed incinerators.) Possible problems: Beware of photographs burning cinders if done as part of an open burn. 

Dedicated burial: Landfills will bury records, photographs, tapes, etc. on site, while an agency witness looks on. Possible problems: Cost factor for designated burial charge. However, it can be very cost effective if a large number of records, etc. are done at the same time. Bio-hazardous evidence materials must be disposed of according to law, and as a rule, should never be buried as part of a dedicated disposal. 

Options for reusing of tapes: 

Demagnetizing: By far the most popular, erases tapes completely. Provides for reuse by agency. Possible problems: Takes time and special unit to erase tapes. Low quality tapes could inadvertently become part of the replacement tape system. Recording on low quality tapes can. damage/destroy equipment. 

Options for reusing photographs: 

Occasionally, academy instructors or other law enforcement agencies will request copies of photographs for educational or anti-crime campaigns. While the request is well intentioned, some states have permitted successful lawsuits for stress when the photograph was recognized by a loved one of the victim. In one instance, a California teenage drunk driver and two friends died in a car accident in Alameda County. Photographs were requested by an agency in Santa Clara County (20 miles away) for a "Don't Drink and Drive" program. Both agencies were sued when a relative of the dead driver recognized the car's license plate in the photo (no bodies were shown.) If photos are to be released. strong guidelines are recommended. 

Back to Table of Contents


Copyright © 1999 International Association for Property and Evidence, Inc.
Reprinted from the Evidence Log, Volume 1994, Number 1, Page 9

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Wachter's Web Works - Quality Web Design.
Contact Webmaster
Revised: 10/06